For extra drinks product evaluations, see our purchaser’s guides to craft whisky, traditional whisky, bourbon and way more in our devoted evaluations part with over 400 professional evaluations.
Leap to:
Finest Scotch whisky to purchase at a look
Finest mild Scotch: Glenkinchie 12 12 months previous, £45.75Best sherry cask aged Scotch: The Dalmore 12 Yr Previous Sherry Cask Choose, £79.99Best younger Scotch: Wolfburn Northland, £46.90Best peat Scotch: Highland Park 12 12 months previous, £45.61Best traditional Scotch: Benromach 10 12 months previous, £41.95Best smoky whisky: Ardbeg 10 12 months previous, £48Best lengthy aged whisky: Lagavulin 16 12 months previous, £83.50Best impartial whisky: Gordon & MacPhail Discovery Miltonduff 10 12 months previous, £49.50Best Scotch whisky for rookies: Caol Ila 12 12 months previous, £53.95Best Scotch whisky for an accessible Speyside: GlenAllachie 15 Yr Previous, £78.99
What’s scotch whisky?
With roots tracing again to Fifteenth-century tax data, Scotch whisky is a sort of whisky produced in Scotland, distilled from malted barley or grain and aged in oak barrels for at least three years. Alongside its ageing course of, Scottish whisky differs from different types when it comes to elements (made primarily from malted barley or a mixture of grains), the manufacturing course of and flavour profiles. Many regional influences contribute to an enormous distinction in flavour profiles for Scotch whiskey, from closely smoked, peaty expressions by to wealthy, sherried types or considerably lighter tasting choices extra synonymous with the lowlands.
Though particularly standard in Scotland and the UK, Scottish whisky additionally has a really sturdy international presence, with a few of its largest export markets together with the US, France, Spain, India, China and Japan – the place Scotch whisky is so standard, it grew to become the benchmark mannequin for Japanese whisky.
What’s the distinction between Irish whiskey and Scotch whisky?
Each Irish whiskey and Scotch whisky have been standard for hundreds of years. Believed so far again to the sixth-century monks who distilled spirits for medicinal use, Irish Whiskey was the world’s hottest by the 1800s, but prohibition in the US brought on an enormous decline in recognition. Scotch whisky is relatively youthful, however right this moment it’s arguably probably the most revered fashion of whisky on a worldwide scale, particularly famend for its regional range.
Though Irish whiskey and Scotch whisky are each distilled within the UK and have lengthy, wealthy histories, the types are fairly totally different. Scotch whisky is predominantly twice distilled with malted barley or a combination of grains, whereas Irish whiskey usually contains a mix of malted and un-malted barley, triple distilled for smoothness. As soon as distilled, each are aged for at the very least three years in oak barrels. Because of differing manufacturing strategies, Scotch whisky is usually daring, complicated and smoky if peated, whereas Irish whiskey is usually a lot smoother with lighter, fruitier notes on the palate.
One of the best Scotch whisky to purchase 2025
Glenkinchie 12 12 months previous
Finest mild ScotchABV: 43%
Glenkinchie, owned by Diageo, relies just some miles exterior Edinburgh and is without doubt one of the lightest of the Lowland whiskies, a area given to mild, delicate drams. There are only some distilleries left within the space, however Glenkinchie, a stalwart producer of whisky even throughout World Battle II, is now Diageo’s sole consultant from the area.
The nostril is mild and delicate, with flavours of barley and grain, recent hay and lemon coming throughout the pale malt sweetness. It drinks very simply, with a prickle of warmth, ginger and cinnamon, and involves a simple end, nonetheless with lemon notes and a little bit dryness.
It is a very mild Scotch with a few touches that preserve it fascinating. For a spirit so mild, it responds nicely to a little bit water to ease the warmth and open up the lemon notes.
Obtainable from:nThe Whisky Change (£45.75)
The Dalmore 12 Yr Previous Sherry Cask Choose
Finest sherry cask-aged Scotch whiskyRating: 4.5/5ABV: 43%
For over 180 years, The Dalmore has been reimagining what it takes to create distinctive single malt whisky on the shores of the Cromarty Firth within the Scottish Highlands. Specifically chosen uncommon casks from the world’s best bodegas and wineries are particularly prized, as they’re used to age the distillery’s whiskies.
The Dalmore 12 Yr Previous Sherry Cask is a very elegant dram, initially matured in American white oak ex-bourbon barrels, adopted by a full end in a bespoke sherry assemblage, together with an unique mix of nutty oloroso and candy pedro ximénez. The result’s a decadent, benchmark Highland single malt. On prime of the chocolate, orange and warming spice notes typical of The Dalmore’s signature home fashion, indulgent aromas of caramelised orange, ginger and sultanas are omnipresent on the nostril. The palate is delightfully easy, intricately layered with darkish chocolate, cinnamon, very frivolously smoked almond and ripe mango savours which develop additional on the lingering, subtle end.
Obtainable from:Amazon (£79.99)
Wolfburn Northland
Finest younger ScotchABV: 46%
Wolfburn claims to be probably the most northerly distillery on the mainland. Younger whiskies are sometimes fiery. The Northland manages that tendency magnificently, with a far larger smoothness and complexity than you’d count on for its age.
Elsewhere within the vary, there’s no age assertion on Wolfburn Aurora, nevertheless it actually has the texture of a younger whisky, with a recent, mild nostril giving off a contact of inexperienced apple and grass, a little bit smoke and sea air. It drinks mild and dry, with a restrained complexity.
Grounded by nut and a chocolate/espresso trace nestling underneath the recent flavours that roll on from the aroma, the lightness and youth is balanced by a touch of fudge and grape. A mild end accentuates the smoke, whereas revealing a quiet sweetness.
If you wish to lean into the smoke, Wolfburn Morven is frivolously peated, with out dropping the comparatively youthful freshness.
Obtainable from:Grasp of Malt (£46.90)
Highland Park 12 12 months previous
Finest peat ScotchABV: 40%
With a larger northerliness than even Wolfburn, Highland Park comes from Orkney and claims a historical past relationship again to 1798. The distillery nonetheless has its personal ground malting (a standard course of the place the grain germinates on a concrete ground) and makes use of native peat, which supplies its whiskies a part of the character for which it’s well-known.
The 12-year-old is the mainstay of the vary, and the nostril is balanced and medium bodied. There’s an apple notice redolent of calvados, with raisins, a suggestion of leather-based and vanilla-led spices to fill it out. Mild smokiness and a touch of briney air intermingle.
To drink, it continues to be balanced, dryish with the smoke and brine masking a malt sweetness that emerges on the finish, and a slight nuttiness underneath the bonfire notes on the brief end. Superbly balanced and an important introduction to peat Scotch, that is large whisky, even earlier than you get to the aggressive worth.
Obtainable from:Grasp of Malt (£45.61)The Nice Wine Co (£47)
Benromach 10 12 months previous
Finest traditional ScotchABV: 43%
Mothballed for lengthy stretches by one in every of Diageo’s precursors, earlier than being reopened by impartial bottlers Gordon & MacPhail in 1998, Benromach has expanded within the final twenty years from simply two distillers to a small crew right this moment. It at present pitches itself as reviving the genuine style of Speyside by bringing a lightweight and, it’s claimed, traditionally correct peat notice, to the refined spirits of the area.
A barely buttery malt nostril, with toffee, touches of inexperienced apple and liquorice with a lightweight waft of smoke. The Benromach 10 12 months previous drinks deceptively simply, with spicy pepper, mild candy malt and extra toffee notes, the bonfire air restrained and entwined with cardamom.
The upper peat ranges are a joyous union with Speyside’s conventional refinement. When you’re in search of further oomph, the Benromach 100° Proof has a ‘extra is extra’ strategy, which, curiously, brings down the smoke notes.
Obtainable from:Grasp of Malt (£45.48)The Whisky Change (£41.95)
Ardbeg 10 12 months previous
Finest smoky whiskyABV: 46%
Whereas Ardbeg is one other distillery that’s seen just a few ups and downs in its 200-year historical past, it’s onerous to consider that its doorways had been closed as just lately because the Nineteen Nineties. Together with Highland Park, that is an iconic Scotch whisky, and the Ardbeg 10 12 months previous is a superb, if bracing, introduction to the distinctive peat and sea air traits of Islay whiskies.
A peat nostril verges in the direction of coal smoke, with softening vanilla and a few citrus. Pepper and even cleaning soap tuck in amongst them. To drink, the physique is wealthy and easy – a mushy, mild caramel malt sweetness earlier than that peat barrels in. The vanilla provides a counterpoint and retains it from pure liquid smoke, even because the mushy malt reveals layers of espresso, liquorice root and pepper. A wealthy mouthfeel contributes to a protracted end, with extra of that savoury smoke, plus a touch of toasted sugar.
Lagavulin 16 12 months previous
Finest long-aged whiskyABV: 43%
One other iconic Islay whisky, and one which doesn’t stint on the peat smoke heft, the Lagavulin 16 12 months previous has a big and really devoted following. Whereas an 8 12 months previous has just lately been added to the everlasting vary (and is superb), the extra physique and refinement of the 16 makes it the Lagavulin to begin with.
As with the Ardbeg, it has an enormous peat smoke nostril and is simply as intense, however right here it pushes lapsang souchong and brine, whereas throttling again the bonfire. Vanilla provides a creamy notice, together with bay leaf, even because the smoke and brine swirls round it.
As you sip it, that peat comes straight onto the tongue, with the sweetness the smokes brings sitting alongside a barely salty iodine. A full malt physique slowly reveals itself, in addition to a woody dryness and extra spice. A protracted, spicy, candy smoke end revives the lapsang souchong air.
Gordon & MacPhail Discovery Miltonduff 10 12 months previous
Finest impartial whiskyABV: 43%
Past the large distilleries is a thriving group of impartial bottlers (to muddy the waters, a few of them have distilleries, however nonetheless), whose ability lies in shopping for new-make spirits straight from distilleries, then ageing and bottling themselves. Some, like Gordon & MacPhail, even ship their very own fastidiously thought of casks to be stuffed on the distillery.
Completed nicely, impartial bottlings provide high quality, worth, and the surprising from distilleries you thought you knew. This specific bottling is from Miltonduff, a distillery that primarily goes into Ballantines’ blends and isn’t thought to be a single malt.
The nostril may be very wealthy. Comfortable cocoa, stewed raisins, spicy rum, candy malt and a nutty trace on the edges. While you drink it, there’s a little bit aggression in the beginning, however that richness rapidly reasserts itself, with fruitcake notes, extra of the sherry, oaky vanilla and fig. It finishes with nut, oak woodiness and cinnamon spice, including complexity and dryness to a whisky that may in any other case tip into extreme opulence.
Obtainable from:The Whisky Change (£56.75)
Caol Ila 12 12 months previous
Finest Scotch whisky for beginnersABV: 43%
Caol Ila has spent a big a part of its historical past largely producing fodder for mixing, although its homeowners Diageo noticed a chance and began releasing underneath its personal title in 2002. Though the measurable peat portions are as excessive as Lagavulin, it’s an easier-going Islay, one that will help you get your head round all that smoke and salt aficionados so take pleasure in.
A sniff reveals each full and delicate peat smoke, with sweetness and a lightweight ingredient of brine, presumably even samphire. On ingesting, there’s an oiliness too, which follows alongside. There’s a beautiful full, clear mouthfeel, guiding the sweetness, whereas the peat smoke follows after, filling out the area.
Fruity notes with a melon juiciness carry selection to the sweetness, and that unusually simple, oily physique fades into a protracted smoky end and longer candy edge. An Islay that doesn’t overwhelm could look like faint reward, however not everyone seems to be after a bruiser, and when the weather are as nicely organized as this, why deny the enchantment?
Obtainable from:Grasp of Malt (£55)The Whisky Change (£53.95)
The GlenAllachie 15 Yr Previous
Finest Scotch whisky for an accessible SpeysideABV: 46%
Whereas the The GlenAllachie, constructed within the late Nineteen Sixties, lacks the heritage of a few of its older Speyside neighbours, the distillery has seen a revival in the previous couple of years. Taken on by the feted grasp distiller and blender Billy Walker in 2017, it has began placing out a fuller, fruitier spirit than earlier than, with the 15 12 months previous an important instance.
Bottled at 46%, with no chill filtering, it has a wealthy chestnut glow within the glass. The nostril is full and sophisticated, with out being heavy – dried fruit, honey, baked quince, cinnamon, nutmeg and a touch of frangipane. On the palate, dried figs, chocolate and vanilla emerge on a full mouthfeel, in addition to a darkish sugar sweetness that avoids being sticky. It finishes frivolously, a whisper of smoke and the spices and fruit lingering for just a few seconds.
Obtainable from:Grasp of Malt (£78.99)
Extra on whisky
One of the best craft whiskyThe finest Japanese whiskyThe finest bourbonThe finest traditional whiskyThe finest brandyBest whiskey glassesWhisky or whiskey, what is the distinction?One of the best sustainable spirits to purchase
Standard whisk(e)y recipes
Whiskey sourWhiskey bitter mocktail Whiskey highballWhisky cream sauceMarmalade and whisky bread and butter pudding
This evaluation was final up to date in April 2025. If in case you have any questions, strategies for future evaluations or spot something that has modified in worth or availability please get in contact at [email protected].
What do you consider our collection of finest Scotch whisky? Do you will have a favorite bottle to advocate? We would love to listen to your product strategies within the feedback under…
