Claire Holland turned a London councillor in 2014, topping the ballot in Lambeth’s Oval ward, and solely ten years later was elected chair of London Councils, putting her on the head of the cross-party collective of all 33 of the capital’s native authorities. That speedy rise, taking in turning into chief of Labour-controlled Lambeth in 2021, has been characterised by passions for environmental causes and the wellbeing of kids – linked pursuits which align together with her greater than 20 years expertise as a authorized help lawyer appearing on kids’s behalf.
I went to satisfy her within the stately, Grade II listed Lambeth City Corridor in Brixton following the boroughs marking the sixtieth anniversary of their creation and London Councils publishing proposals for “establishing joint decision-making preparations between the Mayor and the boroughs” – a change which, if enacted, would have an enormous impact on the present, much less structured, relationship between London’s Metropolis Corridor and its City Halls in direction of one thing rather more just like the mixed authority fashions that function in Larger Manchester, the West Midlands and elsewhere.
It’s also a time of acute monetary difficulties for a lot of of London’s 32 boroughs, with the hovering prices of non permanent lodging including to long-growing pressures on social take care of adults and for youngsters.
Final December, talking at an All-Celebration Parliamentary Group for London gathering within the Home of Commons, Holland stated she noticed 2025 as “a 12 months of alternative for London” by which housing issues could possibly be tackled and financial progress elevated “because the primary precedence”.
However she additionally warned about “the disaster in council funds” and the “actual danger that councils throughout London will begin to go bankrupt” and not using a strong resolution. To this point, seven boroughs have certified for “distinctive funding assist” from the federal government, together with Lambeth in relation to its housing income account.
The primary a part of our dialog focussed firmly on Holland’s London Councils position. The second half focused on broad points confronted by many boroughs, particularly in interior London, with some specific reference to Lambeth.
For the file, once I teasingly recommended she may search to change into the primary feminine Mayor of London, she very firmly dominated it out.
***
The content material and the timing of the London Councils devolution proposals have puzzled some. Although produced with the federal government’s forthcoming Devolution Invoice for England in thoughts, the White Paper previous it acknowledged that London’s present “bespoke preparations” will likely be retained and that Metropolis Corridor will “draw on present methods of working with London Councils to facilitate collaboration”.
No trace there of a “mixed board” composed of the Mayor and the London Councils govt committee “liable for decision-making over devolved powers and funding” getting a listening to. For On London, Richard Brown, who was concerned in establishing the Larger London Authority, has argued that the plans are extra radical than they may first seem, with implications that haven’t been absolutely thought by. Stephen Bush of the Monetary Instances and Ant Breach of assume tank Centre for Cities haven’t been persuaded both.
In the meantime, Sir Sadiq Khan doesn’t appear overjoyed. Metropolis Corridor responded with an announcement that started with a listing of the Mayor’s personal proudest achievements earlier than including that he has “an excellent relationship” with London’s native authorities and vow to “proceed to work intently” with them. There was, although, no point out of the London Councils concepts themselves, not to mention an embrace of them.
How would it not work in apply? London Councils says it sees a Mayor “who’s empowered to advocate for London on the nationwide and worldwide stage” persevering with. On the similar time, it’s express about wanting to place its collaborations with Metropolis Corridor “on a proper footing” – an ambition Holland set out in her APPG London speech, at which senior Metropolis Corridor figures had been current, as a logical development from, for instance, working intently with Deputy Mayor for Enterprise Howard Dawber and others on the London Development Plan, printed in February with a Holland-Khan joint Foreword.
Regardless of the sceptical reactions, Holland is upbeat concerning the London Councils doc, describing it as a contribution to “an entire nationwide debate” that gives “a possibility to modernise the London system, to take a look at what might work higher, how we are able to get higher outcomes, how we are able to get swifter decision-making”. In being decided to make sure London doesn’t get left behind, because it has been in contrast with Larger Manchester and the West Midlands with the “trailblazer” freedoms they obtained beneath the Conservatives, Holland says London Councils and the Mayor are of the identical thoughts.
“We assist a extremely robust Mayor of London,” she insists. “We’re not suggesting in any respect that any of his strategic powers are eliminated, say round planning and transport. That’s important and it really works very well. What we need to do is have a look at related funding and powers round, for instance, employment and abilities, future progress, retrofitting and so forth, the place we might actually work nicely collectively and in a better manner”.
She argues that, fairly than rendering decision-making in such areas extra cumbersome and compromised, the mixed board would streamline and enhance them. “Issues can take time working with the GLA [Greater London Authority],” she stated. “We will discover ourselves having to barter on a case by case foundation each time, whereas when you have a proper system, that focuses the thoughts. We are going to know the place the choice goes to be made. And we’re suggesting a mixed board exactly so we don’t should dismantle every thing already there”.
Holland additionally frames the London Councils plans as a type of insurance coverage in opposition to a future Mayor being a much less obliging companion than she says the present one has been. Although not chair of London Councils on the time, she was concerned in among the joint working that passed off through the pandemic. This noticed the formation of what’s now referred to as the London Partnership Board, which she and Khan co-chair. “We realized that partnership working at each stage is the place the gold mud is,” she says.
There have, although, been some excessive profile current examples of the Mayor leaving one specific borough very a lot out of the loop. Westminster, Labour-controlled since 2022 for the primary time in its existence, obtained little or no discover about Mayor Khan’s government-backed Oxford Avenue transformation initiative, introduced final September, and nonetheless isn’t completely happy about it. Then, the opposite week, Westminster councillors weren’t invited to Ronnie Scott’s well-known Soho jazz membership the place Rachel Reeves, Angela Rayner, the Mayor and representatives of the hospitality sector unveiled potential new mayoral powers over native licensing selections.
Right here once more, although, Holland expressed confidence that any future additional overlap of native and regional authorities powers, with Mayors probably buying the power to “name in” borough licensing selections they thought opposite to London’s strategic greatest pursuits, might produce higher, co-operative outcomes. “We need to work intently with the Mayor over licensing,” Holland stated. “I’m not afraid of that in any respect. I actually assume we are able to work that out collectively.”
By the use of instance, she spoke concerning the cluster of LGBT venues in Vauxhall which, till its boundaries had been modified, was in her Lambeth electoral ward. This fashioned a significant a part of one in every of Khan’s three night time time enterprise zones (the others had been in Woolwich and Bromley) and was strongly championed by his now-departed Evening Czar, Amy Lamé. The close by Portuguese enterprise cluster was included too with the goal of boosting customized, together with by later opening hours, but in addition bettering situations for staff.
For Holland, then, the mixed board thought isn’t a power-sharing problem to the Mayor’s autonomy, however a sensible mechanism for cementing and enhancing ongoing co-operation between the totally different layers of London authorities. Time will inform if the federal government agrees.
***
There are different issues London Councils hopes to get from the Labour authorities. Unsurprisingly, Holland craves a restoration of misplaced funding, citing large actual phrases cuts for the reason that Conservative-Liberal Democrat coalition got here to energy in 2010: “We have to be resourced. That’s the underside line.” The prospect of multi-year funding settlements enthuses her, as these would improve authorities’ means to plan, as does the dedication to matching funding distribution to native want. She cites a 2023 Institute for Fiscal Research report suggesting that London native authorities funding is 17 per cent decrease than its estimated relative want, the largest hole in England.
Fiscal devolution is excessive up on her checklist too, because it has been for London authorities typically since Boris Johnson when Mayor based the London Finance Fee. Underneath this heading Holland, just like the LFC, contains being given the facility to boost an in a single day levy or “vacationer tax” on guests. In her thoughts, this is able to be collected regionally “and assist us to drive native progress” making boroughs “much less depending on authorities grant and Council Tax”.
In Lambeth’s case, the council, together with native companies, invests in nurturing a customer economic system centred on Waterloo and the South Financial institution. A tourism tax on the tens of millions of individuals concerned might cowl a few of that and, says Holland, be used to “profit our extra disadvantaged communities” too. The federal government instructed the BBC earlier this month that it presently has “no plans” to usher in such a tax in England, however London authorities will likely be hoping it’s open to persuasion.
When it comes to different powers, Holland would really like boroughs to have better freedom to implement street velocity limits, utilizing a system devised by the London Councils transport and surroundings committee. Extra muscle for attending to grips with dockless bikes is one other precedence.
The identical goes for licensing non-public landlords, an space Holland describes as “actually sophisticated” and closely depending on receiving nationwide authorities approvals. “We all know that there are actually good landlords on the market,” she stresses, “but in addition we all know that there are landlords who want to enhance and there are rogue landlords.” Not forgetting tenants, in fact: “Our non-public renters are desperately calling out to have homes which might be match for habitation”.
***
Like each London borough, Lambeth is each distinctive and massively various. However additionally it is city territory with robust themes and contested points present in different boroughs, notably interior London boroughs, on either side of the river. Usually, these concern the tempo and type of property improvement, particularly the place housing is anxious, the administration of street area and native transport, and avenue environments extra broadly.
Holland, taking her cross-party, London-wide London Councils hat off and placing her Lambeth Labour chief hat on, characterises herself as very a lot pro-economic progress, which implies being basically pro-development, as a result of meaning extra properties and extra jobs in a borough grappling with power housing shortages and poverty. “For me, it’s about seeing the misery every day of households who should stay in non permanent lodging,” she says, “and the hundreds of younger people who find themselves not in employment or coaching. We’d like jobs, particularly for the younger”.
Lambeth spent £100 million on non permanent lodging final 12 months. That helps clarify why Holland is unimpressed by native agitation in opposition to improvement, conspicuous in Lambeth down the years, typically protesting that it’s opposing dangerous gentrification. “Usually, the individuals who shout in opposition to gentrification are gentrifiers themselves,” she observes. “And it’s not simply individuals in non permanent lodging you could assist. Younger individuals of this technology can’t afford to depart dwelling. We’ve consigned them to endlessly being with their dad and mom. We have to assist them with being be capable of afford to stay in London.”
Holland enthuses about Lambeth’s work with London South Financial institution College on creating “abilities pathways” with a give attention to equipping individuals for retrofit work, putting in heath pumps and photo voltaic panels and so forth. She highlights Lambeth’s personal progress initiatives, saying these complement and reinforce the London Development Plan, together with its foreground Inclusive Expertise Technique. And she or he emphasises Lambeth’s – and London’s – want for “extra capital funding, each private and non-private”. The previous, she underlines, helps entice the latter, making housing and different tasks viable. “We all know buyers need to spend money on London. They actually like the steadiness and the financial philosophy of the present authorities.”
She strongly defends Lambeth’s newer Low Visitors Neighbourhoods which, like counterparts in different boroughs, have met with some resistance, together with a current authorized problem to 1 in West Dulwich. Holland prefers to name them “wholesome neighbourhoods”, assured that substantial air high quality and street security enhancements are happening and that the streets have gotten “extra liveable for individuals simply to maneuver round in”.
She is especially pleased with the “faculty streets” iterations of the coverage, saying {that a} scheme in Stockwell has seen an enormous discount from the “5,000 vehicles a day that might go down the principle street” and a ensuing widespread sight of “kids going to their major colleges on their scooters and their bikes”.
A founding conviction of LTN advocates is that managing street area on this manner encourages individuals to journey much less by automotive and extra by different means, resulting in an general “evaporation” of personal motorized vehicle use within the wider space. There are ongoing disputes concerning the extent to which that has been taking place throughout London, and concerning the findings of research of LTN results. Holland, although, is firmly of the view that “persons are making different decisions”.
She binds this into a bigger upbeat imaginative and prescient, linking amenable avenue environments to extra affluent companies, the 2 issues combining in opposition to the forces of excessive avenue degeneration in troublesome financial instances. “I took an image the opposite day of a college avenue close to me at pick-up time of all these individuals sitting on these lovely benches made out timber and the youngsters had been taking part in,” she says. “That’s how we make our excessive streets nicer and our areas higher.”
Native authorities can typically be about negotiating settlements, resolving conflicts between totally different curiosity teams and differing, strongly-held opinions, and bringing disparate teams collectively in a standard trigger. Holland’s closing plea is for extra freedom and sources for councils to do this work:
“We’re drivers of native progress. If we’re empowered, we are able to try this. We will’t reply all the issues, however we are able to work with companions to handle the challenges. We’re the important gamers who can carry individuals collectively with the intention to attain shared options, whether or not that’s with well being or policing, our native Enterprise Enchancment Districts, our small companies or dad and mom. Whoever it’s. And that’s the place we are able to get the options. So for those who empower us, we empower the neighborhood.”
OnLondon.co.uk offers distinctive, no-advertising and no-paywall protection of the capital’s politics, improvement and tradition. Assist the web site and its writers for simply £5 a month or £50 a 12 months and get issues that different individuals received’t. Particulars HERE. Comply with Dave Hill on Bluesky.
