The Mayor has had excessive hopes of profitable a transport prize that has eluded predecessors, however nothing appears assured
“Watch this house,” was Sir Sadiq Khan’s optimistic message on suburban rail devolution to Metropolis Corridor after a gathering with Sir Keir Starmer final yr. A Transport for London (TfL) takeover of key commuter strains has lengthy been a mayoral goal, and the federal government’s deliberate renationalisation of rail was seen as laying the bottom for making that aspiration a actuality. The Division for Transport, Khan mentioned, “can be speaking to Mayors like me about which of these railways we are able to take over”.
Since then, the federal government has moved ahead, legislating to scrap rail franchises and setting out its preliminary plans for what the Nice British Rail company (GBR) that can run nationalised rail will appear to be, in addition to its proposals for wider devolution to regional authorities. So how close to are we to seeing the Mayor’s ambitions realised?
His confidence could have been buoyed by the appointment of his former transport deputy Heidi Alexander as transport minister and former TfL supremo Lord Peter Hendy as rail minister. Alexander used her first speech in her ministerial function to name for substantial devolution of the Govia Thameslink Railway franchise. However at this stage, the image of what would possibly occur subsequent is blended.
The excellent news, set out within the authorities doc A Railway Match for Britain’s Future on which session has simply ended, is that the Mayor’s “current devolved duties, together with London Overground and the Elizabeth Line”, will stay in place quite than being subsumed into GBR. There’s a dedication, too, to “proceed to interact” with Metropolis Corridor to develop future preparations, with a brand new statutory function for London’s and the opposite devolved mayoral authorities in “governing, managing, planning, and growing the rail community of their areas”.
Nonetheless, an outright handover to Metropolis Corridor (or different mayoralties) doesn’t look to be inside simple grasp. A variety of “partnership” preparations are envisaged, from “engagement” on strategic priorities and “collaboration” on the supply of rail components of native transport plans, to lining up prepare, bus and tram timetables, to commissioning some native providers from GBR in addition to full devolution of particular providers. For that last step to be taken, the federal government will give mayoral authorities a “proper to request” it, with the Secretary of State taking the ultimate choice.
The element can be mentioned additional, however with the session doc emphasising GBR’s function as a brand new “directing thoughts”, overseeing the entire rail community and accountable on to the minister, some specialists have already detected a pressure. Responding in parliament to devolution proponents, together with skilled former London Meeting member Baroness Caroline Pidgeon, Lord Hendy didn’t dispel this. The federal government didn’t intend to “shut off” devolution choices, he mentioned, however these needed to “be topic to efficient operation of the railway community as an entire”.
Quizzed by the Home of Commons transport choose committee final week, Alexander made the identical level – “GBR might want to stability native and nationwide pursuits” – and added a caveat of her personal. “I might want to suppose very rigorously in regards to the monetary and industrial implications of additional devolution of rail providers, as a result of we subsidise the day-to-day operating of the trains to the tune of £2 billion a yr,” she mentioned. “I might have to be persuaded that if I had been to devolve additional rail providers to a mayoral mixed authority, I might not be carving off extra worthwhile elements of the rail community. I must discover a option to cut back the rail subsidy over time.” Not excellent news, maybe, for the most important income earners.
The Mayor’s devolution ambitions have suffered at Whitehall arms earlier than, with the then-transport secretary Chris Grayling blocking a deal in 2016, having notoriously declared he wished to maintain suburban rail providers “out of the clutches” of a Labour Mayor.
We’re not in that territory, although. “There is a crucial function for Mayors within the newly reformed railways,” Alexander instructed MPs. Nice British Rail can be anticipated to “work carefully” with TfL on coordinating devolved and its personal operations so as to ship a coherent community.
Time to crank up the lobbying effort then. There are sturdy arguments for devolution: in London, it has all-party assist and is in style with companies and the travelling public; TfL’s administration of the Overground has been notably profitable, proving it has the capability in addition to the ambition to develop its operations; the Elizabeth line has proven the worth of rail funding in unlocking housing and boosting development, which could be very a lot in tune with the federal government’s agenda.
However the stress is on to get enterprise instances collectively, with the clock ticking down on the Govia Thameslink franchise particularly. That is very a lot in Khan’s sights. Its “core time period” expired on 1 April and the federal government can now take it over with simply three months’ discover.
Alongside convincing plans for enhancing the service plans, the switch of the present subsidies can be crucial to boosting ridership and income. Khan has loads of objects on his procuring checklist for June’s authorities spending overview already: the Bakerloo line and Docklands Gentle Railway extensions, the West London orbital, and attainable new rail hyperlinks to an expanded Heathrow. Will he have the ability to take what he’s referred to as a “as soon as in a era” alternative to deliver suburban rail underneath London authorities management?
OnLondon.co.uk gives distinctive protection of the capital’s politics, improvement and tradition with no paywall and no advertisements. Help it for simply £5 a month or £50 a yr and get issues to your cash different individuals received’t. Particulars HERE. Comply with Charles Wright on Bluesky.
