On Sunday, Sir Sadiq Khan, writing within the Observer, proposed a plan for Britain to answer what he known as a far-Proper “on the march” in a number of elements of Europe and the USA, and known as for what he termed “a severe technique to halt extremists of their tracks” in his personal nation. The earlier Thursday, throughout his January Mayor’s Query Time session at Metropolis Corridor, Khan was requested by a Conservative opponent about his “key efficiency indicators” for “maintaining Londoners secure this yr”.
The query was a Trojan Horse – a ruse by Susan Corridor, the Tory London Meeting member Khan defeated finally yr’s mayoral election, to permit her to observe up by asking him about organised baby intercourse offenders, in any other case often known as “grooming gangs”. It is a matter her celebration chief, Kemi Badenoch (additionally Corridor’s predecessor on the Meeting), has been very publicly elevating at nationwide degree, in live performance with the agitations of Elon Musk.
What adopted was dispiriting, but in addition illuminating. For years now, the populist Proper, which incorporates Tories similar to Corridor, fellow Brexit loyalists from different events, their mass of media allies and, in fact, Donald Trump, have been wanting to painting the capital since Khan turned its Mayor as descending ever deeper right into a lethal mire of criminality, a metropolis the place no person is secure.
You would possibly recall the ludicrous Tory election broadcast of final yr (pictured), with its portrayal of Londoners cowering in fixed concern because the (now thrice-elected Khan) had supposedly “seized energy”. The tag line “lawless London” has lengthy been gleefully deployed by Proper-wing newspapers, GB Information pundits and the like in response to high-profile offences or any new set of figures that appears worse than the set earlier than.
Corridor is a part of that group habit to depicting day by day life in London as uniquely perilous, with the Mayor on to blame. You’ll recall her well-known declare of November 2023 that she had been the sufferer of a pickpocket on the tube, earlier than continuing to dismantle her personal allegation on reside radio. However that have, like her giant defeat final Could, has not humbled or deterred her.
At MQT she inquired, “simply what number of grooming gangs have we obtained in London?” Taken at face worth, it was a ridiculous query. How can anybody quantify with a precise quantity the prevalence in a metropolis of 9 million individuals of teams of collaborators in a prison exercise that’s, by its very nature, secretive within the excessive? If the Met had such a quantity, it might additionally know sufficient about these concerned to have already arrested them.
However, who is aware of, possibly behind Corridor’s unanswerable query, different motives lurked. At previous Metropolis Corridor public scrutiny periods, Khan has voiced his view that some Tories, Corridor amongst them, use such conferences primarily for harvesting footage that may be deployed as transferable clips on social media and used as hooks for outraged “speaking factors” by Proper-wing broadcasters. He could have a degree – the standard suspects had been at it inside hours, with the standard, unchallenged conspiracy theories connected.
Was there additionally one thing deeper and darker occurring? The convicted gangs these days returned to the general public eye had been from cities within the north of England and of Pakistani descent. Although a born-and-bred Londoner, Khan, too, is of Pakistani heritage. Was Corridor driving at one thing? Did Khan suspect she was? Have been his requests for her to be clearer about what she meant, denounced by Corridor as evasions, actually a coded dare – a problem to her to be frank about some veiled, broader accusation-by-association?
I received’t faux to know what was in both politician’s thoughts. However some issues about their exchanges, except for the contempt every has for the opposite, had been fairly clear. One is that they had been a near-complete waste of taxpayers’ cash. Their sole saving grace was that Khan, although he declined to instantly reply Corridor’s trick query – shrewdly, alas, provided that any straight reply to it might have been used towards him – did present Londoners with some understanding that the sexual exploitation of ladies and ladies varieties a part of the parasitic county strains downside.
One other was Corridor’s ineptitude. Her righteous fireplace and bluster was undermined by her references to “nation” strains, not “county”. It was an incongruous error for a self-appointed champion of ladies and the police – virtually as incongruous as her delight on the return to energy of Trump, a convicted fraudster who has additionally needed to pay a girl £4 million in damages for sexually abusing and later defaming her. Corridor is the Tories’ septic state personified.
Most significantly, makes an attempt to trend an impression of a continuous crime emergency in what’s pointedly termed “Sadiq Khan’s London” – a mission to which Corridor’s MQT effort was a brand new contribution – have a debatable foundation in statistical truth.
Khan quoted some figures which hid as a lot as they revealed, however the newest Workplace for Nationwide Statistics information present, for instance, that the individuals of Higher London to be at decrease danger per head of being victims of violent crime than these of another English area besides one, and at decrease danger than most of that crime leading to harm. The world the place violent crime is most commonplace is South Yorkshire.
The place London doesn’t achieve this properly is in complete recorded crime, the place it tops the nationwide desk, barely forward of Yorkshire & The Humber and the North East. Within the theft sub-division, it’s, I’m afraid, the runaway chief.
However even probably the most pessimistic studying of the numbers doesn’t present a justification for confecting the fiction that crime in London is “spiralling uncontrolled”, not to mention for alleging that Khan, who doesn’t even run the Metropolitan Police, is the responsible celebration, as if, by some mysterious means and in some dastardly secret trigger, he’s intentionally letting it thrive – or might cease it simply by barking a couple of orders.
The “lawless London” fable does exactly nothing to cut back crime, serving as a substitute to escalate the concern of it amongst individuals unlikely to be its victims whereas ignoring the very actual and urgent wants of these at biggest danger. And the politics that perpetuate it are the bottom of the low.
OnLondon.co.uk supplies distinctive protection of the capital’s politics, growth and tradition. Assist the web site and its writers for simply £5 a month or £50 a yr and get issues that different individuals received’t. Particulars HERE. Observe Dave Hill on Bluesky.
