The politics of the East Finish have by no means been identified for being boring. That could be a decorous method of claiming they’ve regularly been factional and fraught. They’ve additionally typically been suspected of malfeasance and topic to interventions from above.
The newest instance got here in January when the federal government introduced that what it known as “ministerial envoys” can be dispatched to Tower Hamlets to, within the phrases of native authorities minister Jim McMahon, “deal with deeply rooted and chronic points”. This adopted McMahon’s receipt the earlier summer season of a report on the workings of the borough’s council by inspectors commissioned by Michael Gove, in one of many ultimate acts of his political profession.
It wasn’t all dangerous. But it surely raised “critical issues” within the areas of management, tradition, governance and partnership. McMahon noticed that it had discovered that “an absence of respect and co-operation between political events” and a “suspicious and defensive” political management had contributed to a City Corridor tradition that was “poisonous” and disabled by an endemic lack of belief. They discovered a wellspring of poison and paranoia.
Consistent with the politesse of public statements he wasn’t named. However on the centre of all this was the Mayor of Tower Hamlets, Lutfur Rahman. His has been one of many extra extraordinary careers in London native authorities this century.
The council’s Labour chief from 2008 till 2010, Rahman was, in that very same yr, eliminated as his get together’s candidate to be the borough’s first directly-elected Mayor following claims that he had secured the nomination by doubtful means.
He responded by operating as an Impartial, and gained with heaps to spare. He gained once more in 2014 regardless of a deluge of media allegations of sundry improprieties and Islamist sympathies, however a subsequent authorized problem led to his elimination from workplace the next yr.
The 2014 final result was declared void and a contemporary mayoral election noticed Labour’s John Biggs, himself a former council chief, change into Mayor. Rahman, a solicitor, was banned from in search of public workplace for 5 years. Then, in Could 2022, he made an astounding comeback, profitable the mayoral race because the candidate of native get together Aspire, which he leads.
However, unhappily for Rahman, a few of usual criticisms made a comeback too. This started with a 2023 Native Authorities Affiliation “peer problem” report. It praised the council’s method to communications and its supply of some manifesto commitments, notably free faculty meals and an academic upkeep allowance for low earnings sixth-formers and college students.
Even so, its 18 suggestions for enchancment described a detrimental “lack of belief between the Mayor’s workplace and senior officers” resulting in duplication, frustration and a “two council tradition”. There was distrust, too, between some councillors and officers. None of this helped with getting issues accomplished.
Then, in February 2024, got here Gove’s determination to ship in inspectors, an extra case of historical past repeating itself. Ten years earlier, in the course of the run as much as the mayoral election of 2014, one among Gove’s Conservative predecessors, Eric Pickles, dispatched a workforce from PwC to the East Finish with a fanfare of a kind not typically impressed by accountants.
Pickles declaimed a few “tradition of cronyism” reflecting a “partisan group politics” that was “to the detriment of integration” – code for alleging that Rahman ran the council for the advantage of his supporters amongst native Bangladeshi Londoners, of which he’s one.
What the PWC workforce discovered was that, particularly, grant-giving, property transactions and spending on publicity have been “liable to abuse” resulting from weaknesses in governance preparations. By then, Rahman had accomplished his second mayoral triumph, however its erasure from the file books would quickly come.
And so, right here we’re once more: once more, Lutfur Rahman is Mayor of Tower Hamlets; once more, a nationwide authorities probe has raised issues about the best way Tower Hamlets Council is run below his command; once more, nationwide authorities has inserted City Corridor appointees.
What are the probabilities of a distinct, higher and extra lasting final result this time spherical for a London borough that accommodates each the opulence of Canary Wharf and among the highest poverty charges within the nation?
McMahon acknowledged that Gove’s initiative had come about as a result of it seemed as if previous enhancements, accomplished below Biggs, have been imperilled. Nonetheless, in contrast to Pickles, he avowed an method to making sure that councils all over the place perform properly “that’s not punitive and is predicated on real partnership”, Tower Hamlets not excepted.
The federal government isn’t simply asking properly: it has issued instructions below the Native Authorities Act of 1999 and the envoys’ job is to verify they’re adopted. However the tone and the method are reasonably completely different.
Formally, the council has been discovered to be failing to discharge its authorized “finest worth obligation“, together with good governance, “steady enchancment” and a constructive organisational tradition. Crudely translated, Rahman has been instructed to spend much less time bunkered with an interior circle of loyalists preoccupied with essential however fairly parochial insurance policies and reasonably extra on being clear, environment friendly and collaborative.
The duty of the envoys is to assist them do it, “performing as advisers, mentors and displays”, as the federal government’s explanatory memorandum places it. Kim Bromley-Derry, a former chief govt of next-door Newham who had been Gove’s lead inspector, is now McMahon’s head envoy, main a workforce of seasoned native authorities professionals.
Historic context is essential right here, a few of it already sketched in. It’s arduous to overstate the legacy of typically vicious in-fighting that has marred political activism in Tower Hamlets this century within the largely poor, most interior metropolis components of a borough that lies a stone’s throw from the wealth of the Sq. Mile.
That has left many individuals wounded. Rahman, love him or detest him, is amongst them. One highly-experienced London authorities determine who, regardless of being very completely different politically and temperamentally, is aware of him fairly properly, has described the shattering results on his lifetime of the controversies he’s been embroiled in.
There are two different essential issues to notice. One is that among the extra spectacular claims made in opposition to Rahman prior to now, reminiscent of benefiting from widespread vote-rigging and improper monetary dealings, have both come unstuck – see additionally right here – or not been substantiated by the in any other case damning election courtroom judgement that eliminated him from energy in 2015.
The opposite is that assist for him amongst his loyal native voters is giant, real and deep. The keenness for him I witnessed once I joined him on a Whitechapel Highway marketing campaign walkabout in 2015 was actual and uncommon – and, it will seem, is undiminished, despite the fact that the councillor majority Aspire gained in 2022 has since disappeared.
He’s accused of giving undue and even improper consideration to these supporters. It would, although, be objected that every one politicians, together with these in London boroughs, domesticate their electoral base.
In some methods, Rahman is a product of an East Finish historical past that goes again half a century, to a really darkish time when Bengali Londoners, many newly arrived within the metropolis, needed to organise their very own defence in opposition to the racist violence of the Nationwide Entrance.
A lot has modified since then, and for the higher. However the legacy of a group politics that was courageous and obligatory within the Nineteen Seventies can at this time take the type of a neurotic introversion that will not serve the most effective pursuits of those that are alleged to be its beneficiaries. John Biggs needed Tower Hamlets to be outward-looking. Lutfur Rahman appears to produce other concepts. Can Labour’s envoys discuss him out of them?
OnLondon.co.uk gives no-advertising, no-paywall protection of the capital’s politics, improvement and tradition. Help the web site and its writers for simply £5 a month or £50 a yr and get issues that different folks gained’t. Particulars HERE. Picture from Tower Hamlets Council web site. Comply with Dave Hill on Bluesky.
