Inside minutes the discuss had turned to rats: rats in bin sheds, rats in drainpipes, rats scratching above ceilings and behind partitions. First noticed rooting in garbage, they’ve since superior, climbing, gnawing, exploring. Rats are suspected of chewing by means of wiring, short-circuiting the intercom system, in order that neighbours overhear one another communicate. Rats have died and decomposed simply inches from the place people put together meals.
“The primary sighting of them was reported again in April,” says Marlice Johnson (pictured), a resident of David Clifford Courtroom, a growth of 49 London Reasonably priced Hire properties in Purley that was formally opened by housing affiliation landlord Southern Housing in August 2022. Marlice’s recollection is that the presence of rats was initially made identified to Southern by telephone, however that motion wasn’t taken till a follow-up electronic mail was despatched through the summer season.
“We had pest management are available,’ Marlice says. “They despatched Southern a report back to say they wanted to fix a wall and fill in holes and put mesh backing on the bin retailer doorways, as a result of that’s how they get in from outdoors. However the job nonetheless isn’t completed.”
Marlice confirmed me in by means of the housing block’s entrance door – the door that stopped working quickly after residents moved in. “We had months with it being open,” Marlice says. “It wouldn’t shut correctly and the deal with got here off.”
On the opposite facet of the doorway corridor, a second door results in the constructing’s inside. That hasn’t at all times functioned flawlessly both. “If it’s not one door, then it’s each,” says Marlice. “Generally, there was free entry from outdoors to the complete block.”
Right this moment is among the higher door days – each are functioning appropriately. However as Marlice and I discuss within the area between them, we’re joined by a few of Marlice’s neighbours, half-a-dozen fellow girls, black, brown, white, with younger youngsters, with sicknesses and disabilities to take care of and extra: folks with heavy burdens and large tasks; individuals who describe being at their wits’ finish merely being residents of David Clifford Courtroom. “Simply residing right here basically is traumatic for lots of people,” Marlice says.
From the start – as in some way feels inevitable with tales of this type – the constructing’s sole raise didn’t work reliably. “We had points with that very early on,” Marlice tells me, noting that it was out of use on the day she and her five-year-old daughter moved in. After we meet, it has been behaving correctly for greater than per week. “However the query is at all times, how lengthy for?”
For some, the raise’s capriciousness has meant annoyance and inconvenience. For instance, couriers won’t deliver packages as much as folks’s flats, particularly if they’re on the upper ranges of the block, whose ranges vary from 5 to seven flooring. This has resulted in parcels being left by the doorway corridor publish pigeonholes, that are solely massive sufficient to accommodate letters. This, in flip, has generally resulted in these parcels going lacking, nourishing a bigger sense of insecurity.
Different residents have been profoundly affected by the raise’s recurring faults. “I’m not glad in any respect,” says certainly one of Marlice’s neighbours, becoming a member of the doorway corridor huddle. We’ll name her Maria, to hide her identification. Some years in the past, Maria’s husband sustained a lot of severe accidents, together with to his backbone. He’s unable to stroll and can’t get round with no wheelchair. They reside with their 12-year-old twin daughters on the primary flooring.
Again in the summertime, Maria’s husband had an appointment for an necessary surgical process, scheduled for Monday 12 August. He additionally had a hospital date a number of weeks previous to that for a pre-operation evaluation. That morning, he used the raise to descend to the bottom flooring in his wheelchair and was then pushed to that first appointment. Thus far, so good. However whereas he was out, the raise packed up. Maria sought pressing assist with getting it mounted, however when her husband returned that night the job hadn’t been accomplished. Ultimately, Maria known as the Hearth Brigade to get her husband again into his dwelling.
Worse was to comply with. Just a few days earlier than the operation booked for 12 August, the raise went flawed once more. Once more, Maria phoned to get it mended, explaining the grave must have it working once more by the next Monday morning. Once more, the job wasn’t accomplished in time. Maria’s husband’s operation needed to be cancelled. She says she has been instructed it can’t be rescheduled till July 2025.
Our gathering is augmented by a person, just a little older than the group of girls. “Don’t get me began,” he smiles, getting began. “This constructing’s a pile of crap. It’s simply nothing however hassle.” He echoes the frustration of his fellow tenants: “There’s by no means per week when there’s not one thing. If it ain’t the raise, it’s the door. If it ain’t the door, it’s the raise.”
One other of the David Clifford Courtroom mums has two youngsters, certainly one of them a nine-year-old with autism and an consuming dysfunction, which limits the vary of meals she will devour. Let’s name the mom Anne. Amongst Anne’s complaints concerning the block is an issue she had together with her wi-fi. She couldn’t get a sign, regardless that she was paying for that service. She recounts a go to from a BT engineer: “He stated, ‘Your web line goes into the raise’.” It’s wryly noticed that had you change into stranded within the unreliable elevator, you’ll a minimum of have been in a position to get on-line.
Again to rats. “I feel there’s a drainpipe behind the bin shed and there’s a gap around the drainpipe,” Anne says. “I hear them in my ceiling, scratching. Is that not a hearth hazard in the event that they’re chewing cables?” One other girl has her small little one together with her. She has an 11-year-old too, a daughter, one other autism-sufferer: “She will hear them when she’s in mattress. She wakes up each morning at 4.”
“It’s so miserable, residing right here,” says Anne. “You don’t need to invite anybody spherical, cos you’re embarrassed. You stroll by means of right here, and generally the odor of lifeless rats is overwhelming. We’ve obtained lifeless rats outdoors, proper on the pavement. Nobody ought to must reside like this.”
Additionally within the huddle is the lone mom of one other main faculty age little one. Let’s known as her Jane. She has escaped from home violence and, due to a hip downside, has problem strolling. Jane has a number of tales to inform, together with her personal contribution to the rat diaries: “I’ve obtained a lifeless one in my lounge wall.” On searching for assist, she was suggested to be cautious about plugging issues in: a decomposing rat corpse is usually a runny factor and also you don’t need one dripping in your sockets.
*2*
Let’s maintain our noses for a second and step again. What’s the backdrop to this torrent of dissatisfaction? What has led to the frustrations of these residents of David Clifford Courtroom?
Totally answering these questions finally means wanting past Southern Housing and going again a way in time. However let’s start with Southern’s latest historical past.
In Could of this 12 months, the Housing Ombudsman, whose position is to resolve disputes between social housing landlords and their tenants, revealed a particular report about Southern.
It was extremely essential. It was based mostly on an investigation of all circumstances dropped at the Ombudsman’s consideration by Southern residents it had decided between 30 June and 31 October 2023, a few of them referring to complaints made way back to late 2018. There have been 77 in all. The “maladministration charge” by Southern, which means its failure to do one thing it ought to have or taking too lengthy to do it, was discovered by the Ombudsman to be 79 per cent. The speed for the dealing with of complaints inside that complete was a sky-high 92 per cent.
The particular report concluded that Southern had “did not take accountability for complaints, delayed in responding and lacked empathy for the time, hassle and misery induced to residents”. As well as, it stated Southern had “did not proactively take efficient possession of ASB [antisocial behaviour] circumstances, repairs and its contractors”.
Tales of ASB featured strongly in accounts of the sad David Clifford Courtroom residents I met. Jane described a combat involving knives happening outdoors her flat that left blood spattered over her entrance door, a combat that may have concerned fellow residents, individuals who ought to by no means have been within the constructing, or each. She stated the bottom outdoors her kitchen has been a touchdown area for dog-ends, used tampons and bits of glass which have descended from flooring above.
The lure of the bin sheds for Purley’s rats, causes Marlice, can solely have been elevated by the failure of some residents to put their meals garbage contained in the bins offered. Residents instructed me it’s more durable to know who within the block is inflicting issues as a result of CCTV cameras that may in any other case assist determine culprits, are dummies – designed to discourage however to not really movie. They want Southern to do extra to sort out miscreants of their midst.
Following the Housing Ombudsman’s evaluation, there got here one other report on Southern, which made comparable factors. In August, the federal government’s Regulator of Social Housing, whose remit is wider than the ombudsman but in addition covers companies offered by landlords to tenants, revealed a “regulatory judgement” of Southern, certainly one of its first beneath a brand new inspections programme.
The judgement might have been worse – Southern was given a C2 ranking within the “shopper” class, which measures landlords’ efficiency in opposition to 4 “shopper requirements”. A C1, prime marks, would have been higher, however a C3 or a C4, the bottom ranking, have been additionally accessible. Even so, the regulator “discovered proof of weaknesses within the provision of an efficient, environment friendly and well timed repairs service”.
The judgement stated Southern was taking “applicable steps to resolve these weaknesses”, together with “resourcing its complaints group”, and had responded to the Housing Ombudsman’s investigation with an motion plan. Nonetheless, at that time, the regulator’s inspectors had “not but seen enough proof of improved outcomes for tenants”.
You’ll have seen that the residents of David Clifford Courtroom have had to deal with exactly the shortcomings the Housing Ombudsman and the Regulator of Particular Housing recognized, primarily a poor repairs service and insufficient dealing with of tenants’ complaints basically.
Why was such a significant supplier of reasonably priced properties failing to try this very primary a part of its job properly? Each the regulator and the ombudsman traced the weaknesses in Southern’s very beginnings as an organisation. It was born in December 2022, the product of a merger between the Optivo housing affiliation, based mostly in Croydon, and the Southern Housing Group, one of many largest housing associations within the nation.
The Southern Housing Group had roots within the earliest days of housing associations in London. It had grown out of the Samuel Lewis Housing Belief, based in 1901 with an endowment by the money-lender and philanthropist from whom it took its title. The belief constructed properties for London’s poor in Hackney, Fulham, Chelsea and Camberwell.
Then, precisely 100 years after its creation, the Samuel Lewis Belief modified its title to Southern Housing Group, reflecting its ongoing amalgamation of different, smaller housing associations and the broader geographical space by which it by then operated.
The newly-formed Southern Housing, though it didn’t have the phrase “group” in its title, was due to this fact a nonetheless bigger and moderately complicated organisation, proudly owning and managing round 78,000 properties and working not simply in London but in addition the broader south east of England, the Midlands and the Isle of Wight. Primarily based in Sittingbourne, it has the full-time equal of round 2,400 workers and had a turnover for the 12 months ended 31 March 2024 of £609 million.
The regulator’s judgement recorded that, post-merger, Southern consisted of no fewer than 31 completely different entities, a construction it was within the means of simplifying. It discovered Southern to be financially viable and ruled properly. Nonetheless, it stated the brand new affiliation, not helped by the weaknesses in its repairs service, was battling a backlog of complaints inherited from the pre-merger interval.
The Housing Ombudsman’s particular report, solely about complaints, coated the identical level in depth. It stated the entire method through the merger didn’t “lengthen sufficiently to complaints dealing with and reaching a optimistic complaints dealing with tradition”. There was a “lack of possession” at play, a view its investigation discovered amongst residents and, certainly, inside Southern itself (web page 12).
A “lack of enough communication” was obvious even on Southern’s web site, stated the particular report, because it was “not instantly apparent easy methods to contact it to complain”. There was a case examine of a lone mom of two younger youngsters who couldn’t get a response to her criticism about her heating and scorching water not working for eight months. Members of Southern’s personal workers reported internally that there was “no sense of urgency” from service supply groups.
It’s ironic that an argument made in favour of the merger was that higher, less expensive companies might be offered if a single, bigger housing affiliation was shaped.
In April 2020, pre-merger, the Regulator of Social Housing had downgraded the Southern Housing Group as a result of its governance and threat administration wanted bettering. The response to this and different considerations, together with about hearth security and the situation of its inventory, prompted the group to restructure on the prime and freeze recruitment additional down in an effort to enhance effectivity.
However the ombudsman’s report data Southern itself saying this “finally induced detriment to service supply and a rise in complaints which it was not correctly resourced to deal with” (web page six). The group had a foul pandemic, in sharp distinction to Optivo, these erstwhile chief government, Paul Hackett, took up the identical place at Southern Housing when it was shaped.
Each the ombudsman and the regulator famous the readiness of Southern to be open to their inquiries and provides assurances about placing issues proper. However their landlord has some floor to make up with the sad tenants of David Clifford Courtroom.
*3*
Jane invitations me into her floor flooring flat. The kitchen home windows, which lengthen to the ground, open on to a youngsters’s play space. The play space is enticing. The home windows, although, don’t look in nice form. Plastic wedges maintain the glass in place and moisture seems to have seeped into it. Jane says the home windows leak, permitting damp into ambiance, resulting in mould which she periodically wipes away.
She reveals me a photograph of her and her mom standing subsequent to the home windows, in a puddle. She additionally reveals me pages from the findings of a surveyor despatched to examine them, set out on Southern headed paper.
Jane isn’t happy with all the things within the surveyor’s report, however attracts my consideration to a putting discovering: “It was obvious that the home windows set up was incomplete.” Jane says she want to open the home windows, “however I can’t as a result of I’ve obtained rats operating up the surface partitions”.
This isn’t Jane’s solely criticism about her dwelling. Like Maria, she had beforehand rented privately and was provided her place at David Clifford Courtroom by Croydon Council, having bid for it within the regular means. “This was meant to be my eternally dwelling after escaping home violence,” she says. “However it might’t be.”
Throughout my quick go to, Jane struggles around the flat, dragging her dangerous leg behind the opposite. It’s what she describes as certainly one of her good days together with her incapacity. However not all days are good. On others, she wants a wheelchair to get about – one thing that’s simpler stated than accomplished. She says the doorways are too slender (“I’m scraping my arms on the frames”), it’s tough to navigate spherical a few of her primary furnishings, the cooker is simply too low for her to succeed in all the way down to, and there’s no cupboard space for her chair.
After we meet, Jane is anticipating to have surgical procedure on her hip in a number of weeks’ time. She says, although, that it gained’t occur; that she’s been suggested that her flat isn’t appropriate for her to return to as, following the operation, she can be absolutely wheelchair-bound whereas recovering. Croydon’s web site lists a floor flooring flat within the block as “wheelchair tailored” and limits bids to candidates in want of that kind of property. However so far as Jane is worried, her dwelling doesn’t do the job.
Jane used to work full-time as a chef, however these days are gone. She says she’s fallen “many instances” whereas within the flat and needed to get her daughter to assist her to rise up once more, and even to name an ambulance. She has a carer, and her mom, who lives and works close by, generally is available in earlier than work to do some cleansing. Jane says she needs to reside as independently as she will, however “tomorrow morning, I won’t have the ability to get off the bed. I’m 28, however generally I moist myself as a result of I can’t get off the bed fast sufficient. It’s degrading.”
She says her earlier flat was simpler to reside in than this one. “That is horrible,” she says. “Horrible.”
*4*
Subsequent, I’m going as much as Maria’s flat, taking my possibilities within the raise. I meet her husband, who’s propped up in mattress. Maria reveals me a few of the issues they’ve with the flat itself. Shifting round it within the wheelchair is tougher as a result of it has carpet on the flooring. The largest downside, although, is the lavatory.
To wash or use the bathroom, Maria’s husband wants assist with getting out and in of his wheelchair. They requested Southern for seize rails to be put in, however the job has solely been partly accomplished. The wall subsequent to the bathroom was, Maria says, judged not robust sufficient to help a handhold to bear her husband’s weight. This implies Maria should accompany him on each go to. She says the hassle of lifting him is taking its toll on her again.
“I requested them to take away the carpet,” she says, “as a result of it’s very exhausting for him to manoeuvre. I didn’t ask for them to try this in the entire flat, solely his room and the corridor. After which to return and verify the lavatory and do what have to be accomplished for a disabled particular person.” I ask her what had occurred since. “Nothing,” she says.
Nonetheless, regardless of these difficulties, the raise emerges because the couple’s best supply of misery. “There are such a lot of points, however the raise is the most important one,” Maria’s husband tells me. Maria elaborates. Hospital appointments of assorted sorts are an ongoing function of her and her husband’s lives. As dates for them method, their anxiousness ranges rise.
“I’m not positive, when the time come whether or not the lifts shall be working,” Maria says. “I’m simply placing my hand on my coronary heart and praying that it’ll not be damaged.” She makes a pointed distinction with Southern’s effectivity as a lease collector: “After we moved right here, they have been very fast, very sharp. For the rents, they have been exhibiting their face. However as soon as they obtained the lease operating, they disappeared. It’s not truthful. No one will come and communicate to us.”
Taking care of her husband is just not the one main caring accountability Maria has, as certainly one of her daughters suffers with a kidney situation. Life can be a lot simpler for the entire household if they’d a floor flooring dwelling, with easy accessibility to the outside.
How did they find yourself the place they’re? Though Southern Housing is their landlord, the flat was allotted by Croydon Council. Like different native authorities, Croydon designates households with disabled folks as a excessive precedence group, however explains that that doesn’t rule out providing them dwellings that aren’t at floor stage, as soon as an applicant’s wants have been assessed.
Low-cost council or housing affiliation properties are briefly provide for everybody in Croydon – the council at present has over 8,200 households on its ready checklist – and Maria and her husband, unsurprisingly, leapt on the probability to maneuver in to the brand-new Southern block. Nonetheless, the suitability of a primary flooring flat for a wheelchair person is, after all, severely compromised if the raise service is fitful. Having encountered so many issues, Marie and her husband want to transfer.
*5*
I’m relaying intimately solely a few of the tales I used to be instructed throughout my two-hour go to to David Clifford Courtroom, and primarily people who immediately contain Southern Housing’s buyer companies and residents’ considerations concerning the constructing’s high quality.
One other story considerations what a resident regards as Southern’s failure to behave speedily after sprinklers have been activated by a cooker hearth, ensuing within the water injury being worse than it may need been and a disagreement about compensation.
Marlice is concerned in a dispute concerning the aftermath of coming back from a vacation to seek out her flat drenched because of a leak from the flat above hers. Southern is paying for her repairs, however Marlice thinks her landlord hasn’t correctly investigated whether or not the leak got here from her upstairs neighbour’s washer or from a pipe related to it. This leaves her frightened that it’d occur once more.
Is Southern attending to grips with the shortcomings present in its service to tenants as each the Housing Ombudsman and the Regulator of Social Housing hoped?
Final month chief government Paul Hackett stated on LinkedIn that as “post-merger integration” – presumably the simplification course of the regulator talked about – continues, their buyer contact centre is upping its recreation.
He recommended an outline on Southern’s web site by its Head of Efficiency Optimisation, Dave Harney, of an “thrilling journey” in the direction of this purpose, mentioning, amongst different issues, “designing, creating and delivering a high quality assurance framework” for the Buyer Transactions Directorate and sustaining “data bases” to “help a resident centric response”. Harney identified that “buyer contact centres are identified for having excessive turnover charges of advisors”. He pledged to sluggish this down and “speed up our ‘pace to competency’.”
Maybe progress is being made. My visited to David Clifford Courtroom was on 18 October. Since then, the raise and the 2 entrance doorways have been working correctly and Maria has acquired a response to her complaints. In that response, Southern apologised concerning the raise, acknowledging that “it has intermittently been out of service for a number of months”. It apologised, too, for not having accomplished all agreed “minor diversifications” to the flat by the top of January 2024 and for having did not overview their case for shifting elsewhere.
The response appears to say {that a} mix-up meant diversifications to the flat weren’t carried out exactly as a result of an pressing transfer was accepted as being wanted as “the property was deemed unsuitable”. It seems to have been concluded at one stage that Maria’s household can be shifting quickly, so “no diversifications minor or in any other case have been undertaken on that foundation”. Maria has been provided £230 in compensation for these failings. Southern’s response to her added: “We’ve got undergone a restructure for the reason that merger to assist enhance our service to all our residents”.
Requested concerning the household’s scenario, Southern instructed me that if residents really feel their dwelling doesn’t meet their wants “we are able to run by means of their housing choices and talk about what help we are able to supply”. Maria instructed me {that a} dialog of that nature with somebody at Southern had left her with the impression that truly getting rehoused would entail beginning over again with a recent utility to Croydon. Final week, she known as me to say that in a subsequent telephone name she’d been assured that that was not, the truth is, the case and that Southern might in precept transfer her and household to extra appropriate dwelling from its inventory. A panel, she stated, can be contemplating their scenario.
In the interim, although, Maria, Marlice, Anne, Jane and others have been feeling like victims of an unresponsive and even obstructive forms that has repeatedly did not get a decisive grip on their usually very distressing conditions. They, and others, really feel the constructing as a complete is of poor high quality. They usually query the housing affiliation’s dedication to their happiness basically.
“It feels prefer it’s very discriminatory, how we’re being handled,” Marlice says. Anne’s view is analogous: “Once you’re a social housing tenant you’re made to really feel you should be grateful. The angle is ‘Why are you moaning?’”
For Marlice, “It’s gone previous the purpose of complaining. For some time, you can sort of filter a number of it out while you walked into your individual flat, however now you possibly can’t as a result of there are such a lot of issues with rats within the partitions or repairs that haven’t been accomplished and other people above you who’re simply loud and haven’t any take care of anyone else.”
*6*
I contacted Southern concerning the scenario with the block, initially asking them to touch upon the issues with the doorways, the raise and the rats, and with delinquent behaviour. In a press release dated 25 November 2024 they stated they have been “working intently with our residents at David Clifford Courtroom to resolve the problems they’ve raised with us”.
On rats, the assertion stated that extra bins have been ordered in an try to scale back “overflowing garbage” and added that their pest management contractor was “because of go to a number of instances over the following two months to hold out therapy” and likewise conduct “proofing works” on order to “seal off any entry factors for pests”.
Southern apologised for the issues with the raise, however stated it has been mounted and dealing correctly since 8 October. They acknowledged receiving “studies of harm on a number of events to the communal entrance door because of the closing mechanism being tampered with” however stated it was now mounted and safe. The assertion expressed confidence that the door entry system as a complete which, as Marlice had defined, has been modified for the reason that block was opened.
The assertion additionally stated Southern takes studies of anti-social behaviour “extraordinarily critically” and that there have been no excellent circumstances at the moment, having closed the newest one in June. Unexpectedly, it stated Southern was “unaware of any points with the home windows” and urged any resident with such considerations to get in contact.
I had requested if somebody in a senior place on the housing affiliation would communicate to me, however this request was not taken up. Puzzled by the reply about Jane’s home windows, I despatched Southern {a photograph} of one of many pages from the surveyor’s report – the one with Southern’s brand on the head of the web page proven above that stated the set up of the home windows was incomplete.
I additionally requested Southern if it was proud of the usual of the constructing work, which was accomplished by Guildmore Ltd, an organization based mostly in Bromley, at a value of £40 million. And I requested if it was appropriate that some, maybe all, of the block’s CCTV cameras have been dummies. Southern replied, saying that they might not be offering me with any additional assertion.
*7*
These are, no doubt, very tough instances for all suppliers of reasonably priced housing, councils and housing associations alike. Financially, just like the homebuilding sector as a complete, they’re struggling to make their numbers add up. Together with the commonly unhelpful financial circumstances, Grenfell’s legacy casts a protracted shadow – eradicating flamable cladding and needing to adapt to new security necessities price cash and trigger hold-ups.
Addressing these issues can, in flip, generate additional ones. In a latest discuss for The London Society, Richard Blakeway, the Housing Ombudsman himself, anticipated an increasing number of mergers of housing associations as a method to relieve monetary pressures and these, in a context the place London’s varied housing crises are so overwhelming, producing “a creeping normalisation of responses, a type of tolerance of issues that aren’t tolerable”.
The horrors Grenfell, after all, additionally hang-out the ideas of disillusioned residents of David Clifford Courtroom – a tragic state of affairs for a block named in reminiscence of a former Optivo board member. They’re decided and they’re persistent. Having already approached native MP, Chris Philp, to return to their support, Marlice has now contacted certainly one of her three native councillors and awaits his reply.
In the meantime, Southern Housing continues to pledge to enhance its service to these residing in its properties. Marlice, Maria, Anne, Jane and fellow residents shall be following their progress intently.
Many due to the residents of David Clifford Courtroom for giving their time.
OnLondon.co.uk offers distinctive protection of the capital’s politics, growth and tradition. Assist the web site and its writers for simply £5 a month or £50 a 12 months and get issues that different folks gained’t. Particulars HERE. Observe Dave Hill on Bluesky.
