There’s a German phrase, “dunkelflaute”, which interprets as “darkish doldrums” – durations when there isn’t any wind or solar to generate electrical energy (making you reliant on coal and Russian gasoline, if you happen to occur to have shut down all of your nuclear energy vegetation). London’s housing market appears to be dealing with darkish doldrums in the intervening time: costs are caught in a rut, residential planning permissions are at half the extent they had been 5 years in the past, and transaction volumes and new constructing have slowed to a crawl.
Property costs in London shot up after the monetary disaster, however have risen far much less dramatically since 2016, consequently, property analyst Neal Hudson suggests, of harder regulation of residential mortgages and extra taxation of property funding. The market boomed briefly from 2020 to 2022, however has fallen again since then. In response to the Nationwide Constructing Society’s index, common costs had been ten per cent increased in 2024 than eight years earlier, however that could be a 15 per cent fall as soon as inflation is taken into consideration.
After many years of hovering costs, certainly cheaper housing is sweet information for any person? The Nationwide knowledge present that the typical worth paid by a first-time purchaser in London is now lower than 9 occasions median earnings, the bottom ratio for ten years. Rental affordability additionally appears to be enhancing, with authorities figures exhibiting common rents taking over round 40 per cent of median earnings of renting households in 2022/23, in comparison with 57 per cent in 2016/17.
However neither of those figures tells the entire story. To paraphrase Withnail, residing in London is turning into cheaper for many who can afford it, however stays prohibitively costly to those that can’t.
Cheaper homes are solely cheaper if you happen to don’t must borrow cash. For first-time consumers, rising rates of interest have wolfed up any financial savings from worth falls: in 2020-22 Nationwide calculated that mortgage funds accounted for round 50 per cent of first-time consumers’ take-home pay.
Rising rates of interest pushed that as much as 66 per cent on the finish of final yr, although it has fallen again to round 60 per cent since then (the same stage to 2016). And, even with decrease costs, London consumers nonetheless want to seek out deposits of £110,000 – a gargantuan sum for anybody with out blockbuster bonuses, entry to the Financial institution of Mum and Dad, or no less than someplace to dwell rent-free (and probably vacation and fun-free too) whereas they scrimp and save.
As Paul Johnson of the Institute for Fiscal Research just lately noticed, which means anybody with out rich mother and father or someplace to remain rent-free will discover it rather more tough to maneuver into their very own property in London and to take pleasure in every little thing the capital provides.
This won’t matter if the Levelling Up dream of wonderful jobs all over the place had been realised. But it surely hasn’t, and London ought to be capable to supply alternatives for all, not simply these fortunate sufficient to have been born inside the M25.
Obvious enhancements in rental affordability additionally obscure a much less optimistic actuality. Authorities figures present that between 2016/17 and 2022/23, rents fell from 57 to 40 per cent of family earnings for individuals renting. However for somebody incomes median wages in London, lease fell from 59 per cent to 53 per cent of gross earnings over the identical interval – a big drop, however a lot smaller than that implied by the official figures.
Why have renters’ family incomes elevated quicker than median wages? It might be a results of an rising variety of renting households having a couple of earner, or possibly decrease earners being squeezed out of the non-public rental market altogether.
Each cloud has a cloudy lining. If stagnant home costs will not be doing a lot for renters or first-time consumers, they’re doing even much less for housebuilding. In 2023/24, round 32,000 dwellings had been added to London’s housing inventory, the bottom stage since 2014/15, when the town was nonetheless rising from the monetary disaster. These embody conversions and adjustments of use (together with the dwindling variety of office-to-residential conversions). And solely 33,000 new residential items got planning permission in 2023/24 – means beneath the height of 80,000 plus annually between 2014/15 and 2018/19.
When costs fall, housebuilding slows, nearly as a thermostatic response. Builders base their enterprise plans on a spread of projections, together with adjustments in home costs and construct prices. If costs go up quicker than prices, constructing goes forward. However in a stagnant market with excessive development inflation, plans are paused or slow-pedalled.
After the monetary disaster, housing associations had been in a position to take up a few of the slack, finishing a median 7,000 houses annually within the 5 years from 2008/09. However their output previously 5 years has been half that, as the necessity to fund security enhancements and squeezed grant ranges have lowered capability. Native authorities have began constructing extra, finishing 3,000 items previously two years alone, however there’s nonetheless a niche.
The darkish doldrums can’t final eternally. Rates of interest are forecast to fall subsequent yr (if not as quick as beforehand predicted), which can assist extra first-time consumers to benefit from decrease costs. As well as, whereas provisional figures for housing begins in 2023/24 are the bottom since 2020/21, development economist Noble Francis has noticed that brick deliveries, an excellent main indicator for housebuilding exercise, had been 21 per cent increased in October than a yr earlier.
There may be additionally Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner’s shake-up of planning, closely trailed in interviews and newspaper items final weekend. Will this be sufficient to treble London’s home constructing price to be able to obtain its 80,000 houses a yr goal? What different adjustments could be wanted? Watch this house.
OnLondon.co.uk supplies distinctive protection of the capital’s politics, growth and tradition. Assist the web site and its writers for simply £5 a month or £50 a yr and get issues that different individuals received’t. Particulars HERE. Comply with Richard Brown on Bluesky.
