Air Fryer Cheese Toastie

By Emily Leary. Final up to date Mar 24, 2025. Inexperienced hyperlinks are Amazon hyperlinks. As an Amazon Affiliate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Is it attainable to make an air fryer cheese toastie nearly as good as one you’d make in a pan or press? Sure, it’s! This recipe is made with good high quality white bread, somewhat mustard, and two varieties of cheese with ooey, gooey outcomes.

A cheese toastie is a kind of easy, comforting meals that by no means goes out of fashion.

The mixture of crisp, buttery bread and gooey, molten cheese is irresistible, whether or not you’re making it for a fast lunch or a late-night snack.

Utilizing an air fryer takes out the guesswork, guaranteeing an evenly golden, crunchy exterior while not having to flip the sandwich mid-cook.

The mix of mature (sharp) cheddar and mozzarella strikes an ideal steadiness between flavour and texture.

Cheddar brings a wealthy, savoury sharpness, whereas mozzarella ensures that satisfying, stretchy soften.

The mustard provides only a trace of tang, reducing by the richness and enhancing the general depth of flavour. A pinch of black pepper brings somewhat heat, rounding all the pieces out.

Selecting the best bread is essential to getting the most effective texture. A very good-quality crusty white loaf works nicely, offering construction with out turning into too dense.

Sourdough or a seeded bloomer may add further flavour and crunch, if that is your desire. Whichever bread you utilize, spreading butter proper to the sides ensures a fair, golden end.

For a bit of additional crunch and the joyful nuttiness that caramelised cheese can carry, on this recipe you will sprinkle somewhat grated cheese onto the outer floor earlier than air frying.

This creates a bubbly, lacy, crispy cheese crust that I discover heavenly in opposition to the fluffy interior of the bread and easy ooziness of the filling.

As somebody who loves nice fuss with no nice fuss, I like that this air fryer methodology delivers all of the indulgence of a basic toastie with out the necessity for a sandwich press or frying pan.

Serve it by itself or pair it with a bowl of tomato soup for a basic, comforting meal.

For a smoky twist, you might swap the cheddar for a slice of smoked gouda. And in case you’re within the temper for much more flavour, you might attempt including garlic mushrooms to your toastie, or a spoonful of caramelised onions, or perhaps a few sundried tomatoes to take it to the following degree.

Learn on for the complete recipe with detailed directions and a useful {photograph} for each step. And when you’ve got any questions, simply go away me a remark. Get pleasure from!

Directions

Preheat your air fryer in accordance with the producer’s directions. Mine defaults to 4 minutes at 205C.

Butter every slice of bread. Place two slices of bread within the air fryer, butter aspect down.

Unfold with the mustard.

Prime 3/4 of the cheddar and mozzarella cheese.

Add a pinch of black pepper.

Prime every toastie with the remaining slices of bread, butter aspect up.

Sprinkle the remaining cheese on high and sprinkle with somewhat salt and pepper.

Set the air fryer to 160C/320F and bake for 10 minutes till the bread is golden and the cheese is melted. Minimize in half to serve.

As soon as you have given my recipe a go, I might love you to return again and go away a remark letting me know the way yours turned out.

I might like to see your movies and pics, too! Simply tag me on social media. I am @emilylearycooks on Twitter and TikTok or @amummytoo on Instagram.

Print this air fryer cheese toastie recipe

Extra air fryer recipes to attempt